mystery bags
Graphic reads: All Mystery Bags 20% off until the end of the year! No code needed. Discount applied at checkout.
Embrace the fun and adventure of thrift with a Cake Plus-Size Resale Mystery Bag!
Choose your bag size, answer some quick questions about your size + style, and we will hand pick goodies just for you. Or, subscribe for a mini closet refresh every 3 months with a Mystery Bag subscription.
We offer Mystery Bags in 2 sizes: Medium and Large.
$75 Medium Mystery Bags include $75 worth of Cake inventory. That’s usually 3-5 items that would originally retail for $100+ (MSRP). $130 Large Mystery Bags include $130 worth of Cake inventory. Large Mystery Bags are often 5+ items that would originally retail for $200+ (MSRP).
Subscribe to Seasonal Subscriptions in either size to receive a new Mystery Bag every 3 months for a seasonal refresh! Seasonal Mystery Bag subscribers are also $75 for a medium bag and $130 for a large bag.
Help us curate your bag by sharing your info with us when you purchase.
Before you check out with your Mystery Bag, you’ll fill out a short form with info about your style, size(s), and what you’d love to see in your Mystery Bag.
On the form, describe your style in a few words. Let us know what size(s) you wear in brands that fit you well. (While measurements can be helpful, we can be more accurate when we know your typical size in a brand or two.) Also let us know if there are additional size considerations we should be aware of like, if you are petite, if arms/sleeves are often tight, or if you have a long torso.
We’ll do our best to include what you’re looking for based on our current inventory. Please note that we’ll do our best to avoid items you’re not interested in but cannot guarantee every request.
Interested to see what we’ve included in other Mystery Bags? Need some inspiration on describing your style? Check out this Instagram highlight!
Mystery Bags are available for shipping nationwide or for pick-up in-store!
Shipped Mystery Bags are packaged in USPS boxes, tracked, and insured. You’ll receive a confirmation email with tracking once your Mystery Bag ships. Shipped Mystery Bags make take up to 2 weeks to be curated, processed, and shipped.
Pick-up Mystery Bags are usually available 3 days after purchase. You’ll receive a confirmation email when your bag is ready to be picked up along with some pick-up reminders.
Mystery Bags are nonrefundable.
The joy of Mystery Bags is truly the surprise we’re packing up for you. If you’re feeling unsure or the “mystery” feels more stressful than fun, Mystery Bags probably aren’t right for you. Instead, you can shop with us in-store, in our online shop, in our lingerie and swim web shop, via Instagram stories, or even book in for a Style Session. (We offer Style Sessions virtually or in-store. Folks who are struggling to define their style or find their size tend to find tons of value in a Style Session!)
Mystery Bag Subscriptions!
Mystery Bags have been incredibly popular!
Here’s what folks have had to say…
“Just had to say that I got my Mystery Box and I’m obsessed!!! Literally love every single thing. I did Stitch Fix for years and they never got even close to how perfect these pieces are and I only gave y’all 5 words! Thanks so much. Can’t wait to do another one :)”
“My Mystery Bag was amazing!!!!! So excited to wear everything! ”
“I got one recently and loved it! The pieces were more “me” than any styling service I’ve tried and everything fit like a glove. Will definitely order again!”
“I loved my Mystery Bag. Everything fit great. ”
“OMG MY CORPORATE GOTH WITCHY MYSTERY BAG IS PERFECT! Truly I love each item. THANK YOU, YOU TALENTED FOLKS!”
“I loved my Mystery Bag! Great options right in line with what I requested and some fun surprises. Better than other “subscriptions” services I have used and way more affordable. Thank you! ”
“Just received my first ever order - a mystery bag from y’all and I have only tried them on just now, but I LOVE LOVE LOVE it! All my items were exactly what I had in mind and were in wonderful condition and absolutely adorable! I’ll definitely be buying more from y’all! Thanks so much for offering shipping & being amazing! ”