Embrace the fun of thrift with a Mystery Bag subscription for a mini closet refresh every 3 months! Choose your bag size, answer some quick questions about your size + style, and our team will hand pick goodies just for you.

A subscription will require you to create a customer account. You’ll be billed every 3 months. If your size(s), style, or requests change from season to season, please send an email to update us if needed.

You can expect all types of clothing and possibly accessory items in your Mystery Bag. When you check out, you can also share items you’d prefer to see or don’t want in your bag. You’ll also have an opportunity to share your shoe size if you’re interested in shoes being included. 

We’ll do our best to include what you’re looking for based on our current inventory. Please note that we’ll do our best to avoid items you’re not interested in but cannot guarantee every request.

Large Mystery Bags Subscriptions include $130 worth of Cake inventory without the service fee as a little perk for subscribing seasonally. Large Mystery Bags are often 5+ items that would originally retail for $250+ (MSRP).

Like everything you purchase online, Mystery Bags are available for in-store pick-up or shipping for $10. For pick up, please allow 72 hours before pick up. For shipped Mystery Bags, it can take up to 2 weeks for Mystery Bags to ship. All sales final with Mystery Bags.